Exelon and Invenergy ask FERC to change capacity rules in PJM and MISO

Two companies filed complaints this month asking the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, or FERC, to rewrite capacity market rules. FERC is the federal agency that approves the rules wholesale power markets run on. Exelon filed on November 3 against PJM, the grid operator that serves 13 states and Washington, D.C. Invenergy Transmission filed on November 4 against MISO, the operator of a separate grid market in the middle of the country. FERC A capacity market is where a grid operator pays power plants and other suppliers ahead of time to promise power will be there when demand peaks. Exelon

What did Exelon ask FERC to change?

PJM holds its main capacity auction in May, three years before the year the power is delivered. PJM Manual 18 Exelon asks FERC to replace it with a prompt auction held about two months before each delivery year starts, beginning with the year that starts in 2030. Utility Dive The December 2026 auction would go ahead as planned. Under the current schedule, the auction for 2030/31 is set for May 2027, and Exelon asks to push it to about March 2030. Exelon argues that buying capacity three years ahead is no longer just and reasonable, which is the test FERC uses when someone asks it to change a market rule. Energy Choice Matters Exelon asked FERC to rule by January 31, the last day before PJM publishes the planning figures for that May auction. Utility Dive

Why the timing matters for a large AI data center

Each utility or supplier serving customers in PJM pays a daily capacity charge. The charge equals its share of the region’s capacity need multiplied by the price the auction set for its zone. PJM Manual 18 That charge reaches commercial electric bills, so the auction affects how fast AI data center growth shows up in operating budgets. ChargedUp

PJM’s July auction for 2028/29 cleared at its price cap and still fell about 6,800 megawatts short of its reliability target. A megawatt is a unit of electric power. PJM says most of its forecast growth comes from new large loads, mainly AI data centers. MLQ

The utility company says a forecast can count dozens of new AI data centers that are delayed or cancelled. Customers would still pay for capacity bought years earlier on that forecast. Exelon The price cap FERC extended in April covers delivery years only through May 2030. Exelon release Exelon says moving the 2030/31 auction would keep customers from an uncapped price jump it expects next spring. Energy Choice Matters Exelon also says a prompt auction does not guarantee lower prices and does not add the new power plants PJM needs. Exelon

What Invenergy wants from MISO

Invenergy builds merchant power lines. A merchant line is a privately funded long distance line. It earns money from customers who sign contracts with it, not from regulated rates that FERC sets. Utility Dive

Invenergy’s complaint says MISO counts the capacity these lines bring in when it decides how much capacity to buy. Counting the lines lowers the amount MISO buys. MISO’s rules do not let the line’s owner sell that capacity or be paid for it, so other customers get the benefit for free, Invenergy argues. RTO Insider Invenergy says its planned Grain Belt Express, a 5,000 megawatt line of about 800 miles from Kansas to Indiana, could supply more than 1,800 megawatts of capacity under one counting method. Without a capacity payment, Invenergy says, a merchant line has nothing to sell inside MISO. Megaproject

RuleTodayWhat the complaint asks
When PJM buys capacityThree years before deliveryAbout two months before delivery
PJM auction for 2030/31Set for May 2027Moved to about March 2030
PJM auction in December 2026Goes ahead as plannedStill goes ahead as planned
Merchant lines in MISO buying decisionsCounted to lower the amount boughtStill counted
Payment to merchant line owners in MISONo way to be paid for capacityPaid as capacity suppliers

The timeline

PJM says it is reviewing Exelon’s complaint and will respond at the appropriate time. PJM is also running its own review of its capacity market. More than 30 stakeholder papers are scheduled for discussion at a workshop on November 13. Utility Dive via Yahoo FERC lists both complaints as pending, under case numbers EL27-11 for Exelon and EL27-12 for Invenergy. FERC has not ruled on either one.

Tomorrow’s topic

The Texas bills to repeal the data center sales tax exemption.

The Compute Law Briefs

Five minutes a day so you don’t miss the law behind the biggest infrastructure buildout.

A free email every weekday on AI data center law. New rules, project updates, and some other nerdy stuff that I come up with.

More on AI data center law

AI Data Center Incentives Map

Map

Free Guides and Daily Briefs on AI Infrastructure Law

Home

Large load grid connection and study agreements for AI data centers

Power

How AI data centers connect to the grid (FERC and the power queue)

Power

Demand response and curtailment for large AI data centers

Power